Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) | Johann Sebastian Bach, Andrew Manze, ... |...

Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) | Johann Sebastian Bach, Andrew Manze, ... | MegaBach

classical music:

Bach Edition: Comp...

	Bach Edition: Complete Works (155 CD Box Set) Johann Sebastian Bach, Andrew Manze, ... Brilliant Classics, 2006 average customer review:based on 58 reviews view larger image
	for more information click here

highly recommended

Definitely worth the price, which factors into the rating

[...]This Bach set is an amazing bargain. Clearly the set is geared towards the novice and you'll want to replace individual performances eventually; but much of this material is difficult or impossible to get elsewhere (except as part of one of the two other Complete Bach cycles), and you'd be unlikely to anyway. Plus, there are many very good performances, which alone would make the set worthwhile at this price.

As far as I am concerned, the Hanssler Classics complete set is the best of the complete sets. I've reviewed that one separately. However, it is ten times more expensive, if you can even find it. Your other choice, the Bach 2000 set, contains the Leonhardt-Harnoncourt cycle of Cantatas, which I cannot stand. I agree with Jim Svejda when he noted that Harnoncourt and Leonhards "gleefully take turns mauling the luckless pieces beyond recognition."

One of the saddest facts of musical history is that Bach was not recognized for the genius that he was in his lifetime. His compositions were mostly occasional music that were played once. After his death, they were so little respected that much of the sheet music was sold for scrap paper and about a third of the Cantatas were lost forever. Fortunately we have what we do. That Brilliant Classics has made this wonderful music available at a price that allows a more widespread distribution makes it reason enough to purchase the set.

Brilliant Classics attempted to record the entirety of Bach's remaining compositions on period instruments utilizing the most recent Bach scholarship. 65% of the set are new recordings. The other 35% were licensed from other lables. Now some, like me, much prefer the recordings on modern instruments. I have yet to hear a harpsichord rendition of the Goldberg Variations that is superior to the top performances on piano (although it is a well-known fact that Bach hated the piano, which during his lifetime was little more than a toy). All of the keyboard works on this set are recorded on harpsichord. Pieter-Jan Belder records that Goldberg Variations. It has received fine reviews, but I simply cannot get beyond my prejudices against the harpsichord to comment meaningfully (it is quite lively, though).

That said, and with the reservation that this set is performed with nearly all period instruments, I can recommend it without hesitation at this price.

The Brilliant Classics set has an interesting history. It is based on 5-disc sets of the Cantatas sold at the Krudivat drug store chain in the Netherlands at bargain basement prices (the equivalent of pennies per Cantata). More than 100,000 sets were sold in the Netherlands alone. Pieter Jan Leusink, conductor of Holland Boys Choir and Netherlands Bach Collegium, recorded the Cantatas over a period of 15 months, an insanely short period of time. It is the first digital recording of the Cantatas. There is a consistency of performers in this cycle that is unrivaled, although not all of the performers performed at the same time. Also I find the women singers on the Rilling cycle of Cantatas better than anything a choir of boys can do, despite the unhistorical aspect of such. I doubt that female singers would have shocked Bach--after all, he married one. An interview with Leusink regarding the cycle can be found online.

for more information click here

MegaBach

Well, the price was too good to pass up! And though I've not listened to it all, I've sampled numerous parts of each section. I've not been disappointed by any of the instrumental works--good cheeky period-instrument performances that rank with any of the higher-priced, better known groups. The lute suites are a revelation, since most of us are familiar with them only in guitar versions. The harpsichord concerti are remarkably well-balanced, solo instrument(s) to orchestra--something that is not always the case. I must confess that--as a composer--I've always preferred Bach solo keyboard works on the modern piano (if played in a clean manner, such as Schiff or even the classic Gould) because the counterpoint is better revealed. But any music lover should have both harpsichord and piano versions of these works anyway. The cantatas are generally well-performed; they do have a small "provincial" feel about them, but in a way that adds a charmingly earnest quality to them. The organ works are well played.
The set is very well laid out, making finding a disc easy. The CD included with notes and texts is a bit of a pain in the butt to use. I suggest that anyone ordering the set (and any music-lover should) also look for a copy of the Oxford Composer Companions series J.S. Bach, ed. Malcolm Boyd.

for more information click here

Truly, a great opportunity

I've been a J.S. Bach fan my whole life. I have read about this collection for years and have toyed with the idea of buying it, but have hesitated because of concern for the quality of the recordings and the price. Well, with the price this low, I hauled off and bought it. I've been absolutely delighted.

CAUTION: There are NO English translations provided of any of the choral works. So, just be aware of this.

There is no collection as complete as this one for this low a price. The performance quality is not necessarily the best of the best, but....it is still very well done.

I highly recommend the set.

for more information click here

This is NOT Bach Complete - but near enough

I give this a 5 star rating, even though the performances arn't entirely flawless (thank god). As to value for money, you can't beat it ... I wonder how the performers make any money!? I'm a big fan of Bach's organ music, in particular, and the Swedish organist Hans Fagius' performances are insightful, well registered, and delightful to listen to.

I read some less favoursome reviewes of the Cantatas in this boxed set. They are all played by the same orchestra (a very fine Dutch period instrument group) and the singers, on the whole are good.

If you think you're buying a complete set of Bach's music recorded - you're sadly wrong. For example Cantata 51 (will strings and bells, is missing). Bach's pedal exercises for organ are also sadly missing.

for more information click here

Review by Michael Taylor, Wells, Somerset

Working my way through the recordings. Takes some time. Some classic performances by The Sixteen (B minor Mass)and Kings (Cleobury)for the Passions. Organ performances superb (Hans Fagius) - well paced, on Baroque instruments around Sweden. Cantatas: not all the soloists are good, but look for the recordings with Ruth Holton(sop)who is outstanding. This set is extraordinary value for the price.

reviews: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, page 10, 11, 12

products you might be interested in