Really like the semi interview format of how musicians & other key figures tell it in their own words rather than rumors and second-hand information.
It was really great to see chapters on scenes between the two coasts like Texas, Detroit, Phoenix and others. Perhaps not a complete documentation on the smaller scenes, but not bad coverage either. He wrote mostly about the larger well-known bands and notorious tales of the smaller cities, guess it makes sense otherwise readers will go `Who, what? Never heard of it??'
After reading the book, I suddenly realized that we were a bunch of unstable social outcasts back then, to me it was pretty normal and entertaining. Today if one of my children attempted to go `old school hardcore' I'd do anything to turn them toward another direction.
Highly recommend, it's great to see a book documenting a piece of ugly history that is rarely written about.
I guess that for me, the primary appeal of this book is that it's like a trip back in time to the days when my buddies and I would listen to the latest SST or Alternative Tentacles comps after school, go to shows at our local "underground" venues and check out the record reviews in the 'zines. Before we were out of high school, we'd formed our own band and were appearing on a small stretch of the northeast HC circuit, with some modest success. My early experiences in the HC years fostered a love of creating and playing music that persists to this day. The overarching message of HC, as far as I was concerned, was this: YOU can do this yourself. YOU can make your own music and your own "scene." You don't have to sit back and wait for the big entertainment companies to spoon-feed you. Long after many other aspects of HC ceased to be relevant, this fundamental philosophy at its core continues to resonate with many kids, young and old, banging away on guitars and drums in basements and garages all over the nation.
If you were involved in HC in the early or mid '80s, whether you were playing in a band, going to shows, pasting up flyers or getting your ass beat by violent jocks because of your "weird" appearance--then you will enjoy this book. If not, you might find the "I was THERE, man!" attitude that pervades some of the text off-putting.
It's still worth a read but it's not the hardcore bible or anything close to that.
I'll get to the point with this one, it has a slew of information, interviews, pictures, flyers, ... (the works) from just about every band from the first wave of punk/hardcore up to the mid 80's. The chapter on the Misfits with a very rare interview of Glenn Danzig giving his take on the band, which is well worth the read alone.
For the most part its somewhat poorly written. The author throws in their opion a bit to much, where the book is almost a really long editorial on the music. Not that it would be a bad thing, but I was just expecting more.